A Flock Safety license plate reader remains installed on East Adams Street weeks after Flock was supposed to remove them from Syracuse's rights-of-way. Flock and Syracuse police say the readers are no longer active. City officials are working to replace Flock readers with readers made by Axon Enterprise. Credit: Patrick McCarthy | Central Current

Three months after installing Axon Enterprise automatic license plate readers, the Syracuse Police Department is asking to install seven more of the artificial intelligence-powered cameras along state highways.

In a Wednesday meeting of the Syracuse Common Council, lawmakers chose not to approve the department’s request for the council’s voting session on Monday.

Those new readers represent about a 37% expansion of the city’s network of 19 stationary mobile license plate readers. The city also has had eight mobile license plate readers for years.

The department has characterized its plate scanner program as a critical tool that streamlines criminal investigations, but the surveillance tools, as well as the company providing them, are embroiled in controversy. 

More than 100,000 license plate readers surveil America’s streets from various companies including Axon, Flock Safety, and rival companies like Motorola Enterprises. Flock previously provided the tools to the Syracuse police until city lawmakers cut ties with that company after the city learned that outside entities and Flock itself had accessed Syracuse’s license plate data. 

But a national debate continues to ripple through communities that are reassessing whether the benefits of ALPR surveillance are worth the civil liberties trade-offs presented by their use.

Axon, meanwhile, is facing a class-action lawsuit led by two two San Francisco law firms alleging the company’s collection, storage, and sharing of individuals’ license plate data violates California privacy law.

That debate cropped up in the council’s meeting Wednesday, where councilors peppered Deputy Police Chief Richard Trudell with questions about the value of the city’s license plate readers. The city’s five-year contract with Axon cost $422,636.28.

Councilors last week requested the department provide data that could demonstrate that the tools are as crucial to solving major crimes as the department has said they are since first installing Flock readers in 2024. 

The police department provided metrics on its license plate reader use to the councilors, but Councilor Chol Majok, who is sponsoring the legislation, said Wednesday that the ALPR data the department furnished did not appear to relate to major crimes.

“One of the things that we heard last week was that it helped with homicide and all of that sensitive cases,” Majok said. “As we look at the data… it doesn’t really speak to solving specific sensitive cases like that. Are we just not reading it correctly?”

Trudell told Majok that there was not a direct connection from the data to successful outcomes in police investigations, and that an individual ALPR hit could not be correlated with a successful investigation.

“I can’t go to this plate read and say that that plate read directly led to an arrest. What I can do, and what we can do, is we can provide you all sorts of examples of investigations or homicides or whatever that where the LPR information was helpful and was successful in an arrest and an ultimate prosecution.”

The department’s readers have scanned 3,352,806 license plates throughout Syracuse in the last 30 days, according to a public log of the department’s data. Of those scans, 1.2% matched plates on the department’s “hotlist” of vehicles associated with a crime, with the vast majority of these hits relating to “suspended registration,” according to the department’s transparency portal.

An analysis of recent FBI crime statistics by the Atlanta Community Press Collective found that city’s crime closure rates on significant crimes like rape and homicide did not meaningfully decrease over a five-year period, despite the introduction of thousands of plate scanners to the Atlanta metropolitan area.

Councilor Hanah Ehrenreich said that, absent more information on the value ALPRs provide in solving homicides, the portal appeared to show that suspended registrations and stolen vehicles were the main crimes that the license plate readers are proving useful. 

“I think we are all committed to the safety of New Yorkers en masse. I just don’t know if it’s worth the price tag of the system that we have, if convictions aren’t coming forward from it,” Ehrenreich said. “I also don’t know if it’s worth a mass surveillance system where we are monitoring every plate in order to winnow out the ones that have suspended registrations.”

Ehrenreich, who in February broke with her colleagues and voted against the Axon contract, asked Trudell if the license plate readers have helped the department recover stolen vehicles faster.

“I don’t think we can equate a quicker recovery to an LPR hit,” Trudell said.

When the department first sought to implement the tools in 2023, former Police Chief Joseph Cecile said ALPRs would help solve significant crimes faster.

Trudell, though, said the value license plate readers provide should not be judged by that metric alone, and argued the ALPR program provides a more holistic value to the city.

“I don’t know that I would state the weight and the worth of the LPR system solely on the stolen vehicles, even though they’re a greater number,” Trudell said. “I think the value to society, the value to our Syracuse community, is solving a smaller group of violent crime, and I think it’s a quality over quantity argument.”

Councilor Rasheada Caldwell supported Trudell’s perspective. Even so, Caldwell also called on the department to furnish more information on how and when ALPRs have helped the department investigate homicides. 

“If it stops one, if it prevents one, it’s worth every dollar,” Caldwell said. 

Councilor Corey Williams pointed out that the council was not considering whether the department should have ALPRs or not, but rather whether the department should install more.

Williams described the legislation under consideration as an expansion of the department’s program, which Trudell pushed back against. Trudell told the council that the legislation was “a formality” because the council had approved the department’s plan to operate 26 license plate readers earlier in the year.

The item the council considered Wednesday would grant permission to Axon to install seven license plate readers on the state right of way.

“It’s more of an engineering formality to put that license plate reader at that location. You already approved this number of cameras,” Trudell said.

Council President Pro Tempore Jimmy Monto disagreed.

“We will remind you that we have the ability to approve or revoke anything at any point,” Monto said.

The data the department provided, and Trudell’s subsequent answers to councilors’ questions, failed to win over skeptical lawmakers. Majok held the item from the council’s agenda for its Monday voting session, saying there were “a lot of questions left to be answered.”

Trudell said the department would work to provide the information the councilors requested, and reiterated that the department is preparing its first audit of its license plate reader program. The police department in 2023 pledged to perform regular audits of its ALPR program and to publish the results of those audits, along with reports on the tool’s impact, but has yet to do so. 

Before the Axon license plate readers went live this summer, Police Chief Mark Rusin told Central Current he was committed to increasing transparency around SPD’s use of ALPRs by publishing the department’s license plate reader policy as well as the regular audits.

The department’s commitments to increasing transparency come as Assemblymember Pam Hunter is advocating for sweeping statewide regulations that would change how local agencies could use license plate readers, which she has said constitute a “constant, warrantless surveillance system.” 

Hunter is sponsoring legislation in the State Assembly to restrict warrantless data-sharing with out-of-state entities, limit data retention periods to 48 hours or less, and restrict use cases.

Some other states have gone further: Vermont enacted a ban on all license plate readers that begins in July 2027, Texas banned installation of new Flock ALPRs, and Florida banned most ALPRs from state roadways. In the U.S. Congress, bipartisan support for regulations on license plate readers is growing.

Councilor Donna Moore on Wednesday said seeing more data from SPD on how it uses its license plate readers would not just benefit lawmakers, but also help Syracuse residents gain a better understanding of the readers and why the city pays to use them.

“One of the things that concerns me is we’re spending a lot of money. People aren’t really thrilled about the readers, and we really don’t have any outcomes to show to them. How many cases are being solved? What kinds of evidence are being pulled?” Moore said. “… I think we owe that to our taxpayers because they don’t love the readers in the first place.”

Read more of Central Current’s coverage

Photo gallery: The I-81 North ramp to I-690 East closes permanently

The Interstate 81 North on-ramp to Interstate 690 East closed permanently on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, as the New York State Department of Transportation prepares to demolish the elevated I-81 viaduct through downtown Syracuse.

Patrick McCarthy is a staff reporter at Central Current covering government and politics. A graduate of Syracuse University’s Maxwell and Newhouse Schools, McCarthy was born and raised in Syracuse and...