Marty Masterpole, Onondaga County Comptroller Credit: Courtesy of Marty Masterpole

Democrat Marty Masterpole announced today he will run for Onondaga County executive.

Masterpole, the Onondaga County comptroller, has spent more than two decades holding public offices. He’s been a Syracuse city councilor, a county legislator and city auditor. If he is elected county executive in 2027, it would mean moving just across the hall on the 14th floor of the county building from the comptroller’s office.

His consideration of a run for the county’s government’s top job – held now by Republican Ryan McMahon – has been the “worst-kept secret in town,” he joked.

“At some point, I had to make a decision based on watching election results, based on my own internal analysis, based on talking to potential donors and donors who have typically given to Ryan McMahon and Republicans,” said Masterpole. “There’s a path to victory. I’m going to do my best to capitalize on a path to victory, and you know today’s the first official day of this race.”

McMahon has won two elections as county executive, beating Democrat Bill Kinne in 2023 and Democrat Tony Malavenda in 2019 by wide margins. There are about 32,000 more active enrolled Democrats in the county than Republicans. McMahon has more than $1 million in his campaign account to fend off challengers.

(Editor’s note: Malavenda is one of the founding board members of Central Current.)

Masterpole said he would run on an affordability platform. As costs have increased, towns and villages have been forced to cut services and increase taxes, he said. He said his years working in both city and county finances had given him ideas for delivering services at the most efficient cost.

“You’re going to hear [McMahon]’s campaign pitch: record fund balance and low property tax rate,” said Masterpole. “But that doesn’t do anyone any good. There’s a friend of mine who’s said for a while, ‘Stop cutting my property tax. I can’t afford it.'”

The county has decreased its property tax rate year after year. The county rainy day fund has reached nearly a quarter billion dollars, which McMahon has said helped to raise the county’s credit. A self-described “fiscal conservative,” Masterpole said he would hope to find a balance between spending money on services, saving it, and returning it to towns and villages.

As county executive, Masterpole said he would focus on collaborating with towns, villages and school districts to cut costs by creating economies of scale. He gave examples: he would like to allow towns and villages to buy into the county’s health insurance plan, lowering the costs of insurance for their employees. He’d like to buy road salt in greater volume.

This year, Onondaga County is on pace to bring in more than $40 million more than was planned in county sales tax, largely because of Micron’s spending in the county. Masterpole said when the county has unexpected revenue, it should think about sharing it directly with towns and villages.

(McMahon used $25 million of that extra sales tax revenue to fund ONHOME, the county’s new limited development corporation focused on housing.)

Masterpole was critical of several elements of McMahon’s tenure.

McMahon has used the acronym PIE (Poverty, Infrastructure, and Economic Development) to define what he considers to be his main focuses. Masterpole said he was thrilled by the acronym, but addressed each item in it.

“Poverty. Look no further than outside the courthouse and civic center where he works,” said Masterpole. “Then you know that poverty is rampant in the center city.”

With regards to infrastructure, he pointed to last year’s water main break, when six communities in Onondaga and Madison county’s had to conserve water over Christmas. Masterpole said that if infrastructure improvements were being made properly, there should not have been a break.

As for economic development, Masterpole said that the credit for bringing Micron to Onondaga County should be shared with Governor Kathy Hochul and Senator Chuck Schumer. He was critical of three projects that McMahon had had more control over: the Onondaga County aquarium, the Great Northern Mall and ShoppingTown Mall.

He said he believed that McMahon had prioritized bringing corporations to the county.

“My opinion is, everybody’s not going to work at Micron,” Masterpole said, quickly clarifying that he did not mean to “bash” Micron. He said he would be supportive of businesses, but would prioritize differently.

He also criticized McMahon for something he had found in an audit of county take-home vehicles that he’d published in February. The county executive’s take home vehicle, a 2024 Chevy Tahoe, had been purchased by the county Department of Transportation for $70,000, but was not included on county asset lists, nor was it included in the DOT’s request for vehicles or in the executive’s 2024 budget request.

“It’s not the crime; it’s the cover-up,” said Masterpole. “The county executive having a car is not the issue. The county executive buying a car and charging to the Department of Transportation budget, hoping that nobody would see it, is you know where I see the egregiousness of that.”

For now, the two men will continue to work together on county issues. Masterpole said he plans to focus on the audits which are “most deserved,” and will not use his office as a political tool. However, if the county legislature requests a particular audit, he will prioritize it.

Masterpole was confident in his ability to win the race.

“This is gonna be a challenge, but I think it’s a challenge that we can win,” he said.

Laura Robertson is a staff reporter covering Onondaga County. Prior to joining Central Current, she lived on the edge of the Bering Strait in Nome, Alaska, where she worked as a reporter for a year. She...